Revitalizing the Center: The Liberal Wager for the 21stCentury. A View from the United States
Abstract
This essay revisits Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr.’s The Vital Center (1949) and argues that its core thesis remains valid: democratic liberalism is a combative third way between right- and left-wing authoritarianisms, not a passive or arithmetic middle ground. The author identifies three enduring ideas: the rejection of complacent equidistance, the psychology of democratic maturity, and a liberalism that acts as a fighting force rather than a neutral referee. He then argues that its programmatic content requires deep reconstruction in light of four challenges Schlesinger could not foresee: illiberal populism across the left and right, systemic competition with China and Russia, rising inequality under neoliberal globalization, and planetary risks such as climate change, artificial intelligence, and mass migration. The essay examines the November 2026 U.S. midterm elections as an early test of this wager, drawing on contemporary analysts to suggest that a competence-oriented, institution-defending center can prevail while still facing the underlying grievances that fuel populism. It concludes with five principles for a renewed vital center: contesting identity and economic justice, competing for the Global South, recovering a redistributive reformist wing, building binding global cooperation mechanisms, and cultivating a psychologically mature liberalism.